Hey I was just wondering if I'm right about this... does anyone have first-hand knowledge? In this video, it sure looks like a Brilhart Personaline... in hard rubber I think (it looks a bit brownish).
I ask because I've never seen him playing anything other than his standard short shank Soloist, or what looks like a Tone Master on some 1950s records.
This couldn't be an S80, could it? The shank on the Personalines looks a lot like an S80, but my money says this is a Personaline.
I don't think it's an S80 or Personaline. The Vandoren is possible. It also looked a bit like some of the Couf mouthpieces but I just can't see it clearly enough.
Well I've got one of these hard rubber Personalines and I managed to upload this photo of me playing it from my phone... https://vault.myvzw.com/webcs/app/share/invite/sa8ulRY0VU
I hope this link works.
This is it and I call it the Ultimate Sleeper, disguised as an S80, with Selmer ligature and I even have the cap to match.
And I do believe this is what Al is playing in those videos from the 1980s.
Again, none of this really matters... I'm just curious.
As I said, none of this is very important… but I do appreciate the input/ideas.
What I DO know is: Ya gotta love Al Cohn, whatever the heck he is playing!
Can I get a Amen?
The Dukoff was bought from Artie Pincus- When Artie told me I could imagine that on that Selmer he played. I always took note the legends were trying newer pieces. Eg- Eddie Barefield had a Lawton. . you guys know what I mean. Big George had a Lawton. . . etc.
My thought on the odd shaped piece...my guess would be- Proto type Vandoren piece! Al was tight with Kenny Davern- Kenny hooked guys into the Vandoren circle and also Kenny gave Al a few RIA's he had. ( the RIA crystal clarinet pieces were very good. Exact!) In the Poland video I'd bet ya that was a Vandoren proto-type! That was the era Vandoren copied Mulligans piece....I forgot the guys name at Vandoren but he was very good. Jean Paul ....?? somebody like that. Just a thought.
But also I do remember a hard rubber Personaline Frank Wells had in State street shop that he re-faced for Al. It was open. . And he said Al used a 2 reed.
So what looks like a Brill....just might be. Also Wells was known to alter the outside of the piece if he felt the urge!:bluewink:
Then again...I bet Al's son Joe ( great guitarist) has all that stuff as he was playing his dad's tenor a few years ago as well.
I got all these cassette tapes Dick Hafer made me of Al in LA with Lou Levy, he sounded fantastic all the time. I'm gonna go listen now- Dick made a cassette of each set the entire week.
One of those long hard rubber pieces...might be a Frank Wells hard rubber piece. They had a long shape- and were quite good. The projection on that one vid reminded me...it just might be a Frank Wells!
One of those long hard rubber pieces...might be a Frank Wells hard rubber piece. They had a long shape- and were quite good. The projection on that one vid reminded me...it just might be a Frank Wells!
That video gets pretty close in and this doesn't look like the shank on my HR Personaline. I think it's what Tim was talking about. Either a Vandoren or something out of Frank Wells.
Heck now that I watch it more... there's no telling. May be a Brilhart. Who knows?
Sure is a great set, though. Total focus. He really let's the horn do the talking here.
Well that is the best picture yet of this mouthpiece so I went and grabbed my HR Personaline, and I disagree with Jim that the shank in the photo looks "a little long". Its proportions are WAY longer. Also, the beak is not scalloped out (cut low) where it meets the body, which is how the Personaline is.
Somebody had it on pretty good authority that Al played a Vandoren in this period, which may have had some custom/prototype aspects to it, so I'm pretty sure that is what we're looking at here.
The shank looks a little long for a Personaline but that is probably the most likely piece. They play great for one thing.
Al's granddaughter Shaye Cohn has a really fine trad group called Tuba Skinny, and she is one hell of a good cornet player.
Al's son, Joe Cohn (Shaye's father) is also an incredible jazz guitarist.
The force is strong in that family - see nice picture below - 4 generations of Cohns: grandfather Dave, Al (62), Shaye (5) and Joe. - November 24, 1987 (Thanksgiving).
Also, where the table meets the shank, it is offset outward from the shank diameter in the photo. The Personaline is not at all like that. There is no step, just an angle.
Thanks Liam, I took a look on my desktop and now I can see it, including the Selmer lig.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Sax on the Web Forum
3.3M posts
75.4K members
Since 2003
A forum community dedicated to saxophone players and enthusiasts originally founded by Harri Rautiainen. Come join the discussion about collections, care, displays, models, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!