I once heard an apparently well-known classical clarinetist who used (in the classical context) a vibrato and tone that I thought would cut concrete. I found it jarring. (Full disclosure: I started on clarinet and was taught NO vibrato.) More recently, I heard a concert band play "Victory at Sea" with a "jazzer" tenor player who swooped into every phrase and had a vibrato you could lose your car keys in. It really marred an otherwise solid performance. In other words, it's about using good taste and judgement for the context.