What do you think of garage band?

saxgirl9 · 09-29-2005, 03:56 AM

So mac has garage band that lets you write music using loops - what do you think that this is doing to the level of music knowledge composition once required? Do you think that dumbing it down to that level can make anyone a composer? Do you think that someone can become successful writing music using garage band?

Bill Mecca · 09-29-2005, 04:07 AM

can it make anyone a composer?

No, it's a tool, give someone a hammer and they may be able to drive some nails, but they are not a carpenter.

Can someone become successful writing music using garageband?

Sure, if they have talent.

Greelmo · 09-29-2005, 04:53 AM

I write music for television commercials, and Garageband is more powerful than most people think. I use it. However, I don't use ANY of the loops (that's not composing, that's drag and drop), I use it for it's mixing and editing capablilities. As a PS I would like to add that I use Garage band to accompany much more powerful composing tools.

also, everyone has garageband. People will recognize the loops, and you will never be taken seriously ever again if you try to pass it off as your own.

saxgirl9 · 10-04-2005, 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Greelmo

also, everyone has garageband. People will recognize the loops, and you will never be taken seriously ever again if you try to pass it off as your own.

Haha - I wasn't planning on doing that - but that is really funny to see in words.

**A Greene** · 10-04-2005, 02:50 AM

I use it to show my MS Student how much of the music they listen to - particularly Hip Hop is basic loops and simple processing. I allow them to play with the loops and see what they can come up with in a short session.

Personally - At our level it's more like word processing them music. "Drag and Drop" as one person mentioned. Although it is pretty COOL. And then kids can import the piece into i-Tunes and burn a CD or send it to someone. All of a sudden the Band-Guy (which is me) becomes more than just the scales-and-lesson-book guy. (which can also be cool but certainly not INSTANT)

saxgirl9 · 10-04-2005, 07:08 PM

It might just be me - but I see Garage Band as a sort of game. I don't know if I take the program that seriously and consider it more of a toy than a tool.

Although, I can see it as being useful and a great tool. It's just not what I use it for at this point. I'm more of a pro tools and m-box person.

Bill Mecca · 10-04-2005, 07:32 PM

toy or tool, your choice...

now where is that cellist I hired to be here at 2 p.m.?

1stchair · 10-05-2005, 02:30 AM

Use Sibelius

saxgirl9 · 10-06-2005, 07:46 PM

I actually use finale! sorry