Vandoren V5 (s35) or Selmer SS (I or J)

[*TheEdge*]

OK. I want to move into a jazz mpc for my soprano. I'm currently switching between a Morgan ProTone and a Yamaha 4C. Both fairly closed pieces. I've been reading about the Vandoren V5 (S35) and Selmer SuperSsession (I or J facing). Any suggestions? Which is better?

[No Clever Name]

Well, sorry, I can't really tell you which I like better, as I haven't played a super session. I have played the vandoren, and I do like that piece... but my main purpose of posting is to second your question... What say you all about the differences between the SS and the S35?

[Dave Dolson]

I'm not trying to be a wise-guy here, but the question of which mouthpiece is better than another mouthpiece is endless . . . and unanswerable. It is the same with saxophone manufacturers and/or models. It ALL has to do with what the individual player likes, and NOTHING to do with what I or some other poster likes. It is just too personal and there are too many variables for any of us to answer your question(s). All we can offer are opinions - and those are not very helpful to others who have different embouchures, horns, musical concepts, and needs.

Most posters know my position on soprano mouthpieces - Super Sessions in J are the best I've ever played. Does that mean they are the best? No, because I may well come across something else that plays better for ME. But so far, I haven't - and I've been playing and buying for many years.

I recommend that you either go to a store that has both in stock and will allow a test OR buy both pieces - then you can test them and make your own decision. That's what most of us have done over the years - and we have boxes of best-players (or we took a risk and bought something that didn't quite meet our needs) that were eventually superceded by some other hot ticket. Good luck in your mouthpiece search. DAVE

[MojoBari]

They are worth trying. Consider also a S25 for more stable pitch control if needed. I like HR Ponzols/Barones/Baris around .065". All 3 are similar (appear to be from the same blank).

[retread]

I've not played the Vandoren, but I do have a Super Session I. It's a very nice mouthpiece. But my favorite is the Tenney Link. To me it has a richer sound and is a bit easier to play.

[*TheEdge*]

Thanks for the help.

[Mike Ruhl]

Mojo makes a good point (as usual): considering what you're used to playing, it may be better to split the difference and try the Vandoren S25 or Super Session H or I facings first. The S35 and SS J facings are pretty open.