PDA

View Full Version : R1 Jazz Vintage Gold Alto Reviewed


jjgold
11-12-2004, 02:17 AM
Ok. Here is how all this started. I have a SX-90 Bari. Killer horn but when I play longer than an hour my right hand gets a bit sore. So I have been thinking of trying something new. Problem is that I think the SX-90 Bari is the Best Modern Bari made and I need the low A (so a vintage Bb horn is outta the ?). Anyhow I have been hearing little voices in my head (not really) about these Rampones and how James Carter is playing them and some other cats. I bought that one that was for sale in the "for sale" section.

WOW! What A KILLER horn that Bari is. I think I liked it better than my SX-90. Problem is that I was told it was the R1 Jazz and it was only the R1. Also, I hated the flash plating. Well I thought maybe I ought to give this R1 Jazz Bari a run. But, nobody knows anything about these damn horns. So it was either wait and keep getting arthritis or buy one w/o playing it for like $6k. :oops:

Well my decision was to buy the Alto. Less at risk and if it was as good as I am hearing than I will sell my current alto (a late 60's Superba 1 that is now the second best alto I have owned). So my purchase options were either Saxophone UK. or Saxforte. Why buy overseas when I can get the same horn here and support the states. But it is more than just that. Matt Aaron at SaxForte was VERY helpful. He did NOT tell me how great the horn was. (It seems like the music business is littered with snake oil salesman who tell you how great you will be on this or that. not that I ever listened.) What he did do was had some good conversations with me and finally said you know I think you would really dig this horn.

Well I got the horn today. I have opened many sax cases of horns I have tried and purchased in the past. But, this was the FIRST time I ever was really just blown away from the horn. The Vintage Heavy Gold Platinging is beautiful. It is almost like who cares how it plays look at the way it looks. i want to buy the bari and tenor to display as art. These things are very different creatures. I have owned almost every sax new and used (VI, Cannonball, Top Hat, The Martin, Super 20, 992, SX-90, 6M, Couf, Series III, and II, and many I can't remember). The richness and complexity of sound is nothing I can remember hearing. Plus you can get that VI type buzz (like that Maceo Thing or the Fat Meat of Cannonball in the same breath.) It is almost too loud but has a something to the sound that is pleasing to the ear. That is one of the problems I found in the New Borgani. I thought it was kinda neat but the sound was just loud and almost aesthetically annoying. Plus, I was not too hapy with the fit and finsh of the Borg, it almost felt cheap.

Well with the Rampone, you can tell that there were live hands that went into this thing and it just feels crafted(?).

The altssimo was the best I have played. I can usually go to C4. Mostly with the same fingereing just do it with my throat. This horn was effortless. I need to spend some more time with it. But you may tell I am enjoying the experience. I will report more when I get fully acclimated with it. Uh, anyone want to buy a Couf Alto? :oops:

Morry
11-12-2004, 07:25 AM
Well, when you get ready to unload that SX-90 bari, let me know. I'll probably be in the market.

jjgold
11-12-2004, 12:17 PM
Ok Morry. give me an email...

jjgold007@aol.com

jaankaden
11-12-2004, 01:18 PM
morry's gonna have an SATB setup entirely made up of keilwerths!!!

Morry
11-12-2004, 05:46 PM
None of which I could really afford. :-)

xuanvu
11-12-2004, 05:54 PM
jjgold,
Sounds great!!! Do you have any picture of the alto? I would love to see them.

Thanks,
Kenny.

jjgold
11-13-2004, 04:34 PM
You know I could take pics but just go to the SaxFort website. Those are better pics I could ever take. The pics of the horn DO NOT do the horn its due. You gotta see in person.

bkiser
11-13-2004, 11:05 PM
How are the ergonomics on the horn? Balanced and smooth? Pearls cupped or flat? Does it have a similar "feel" to any of the well-known brands?

I am also looking for a new alto, but not willing to take the chance on the no-return policy of saxforte at this point.

saxforte
11-14-2004, 12:43 AM
C'mon down Brian!

bkiser
11-14-2004, 01:32 AM
Doh! Busted complaining about a vendor policy! :D

I played a few horns (altos) this week- a couple of Guardalas, Yamaha 875, and the Ref 54. The Selmer was far and away the best I played. It was not the best setup, so there were some tuning issues, but I thoroughly enjoyed everything I played on it. Still...if the R1 Jazz plays and FEELS as good as it looks in Vintage Gold....WOW!

jjgold
11-14-2004, 01:40 AM
"How are the ergonomics on the horn? Balanced and smooth? Pearls cupped or flat? Does it have a similar "feel" to any of the well-known brands?"

Ergos are very good! Selmeresqued sort of. i think the left hand table is better. But do you have big hands or small hands?

Very Balanced. But remember this is a hand made horn. Key Cups have a subtle indentation.

Is it similar to any of the current horns. it is louder and brighter with the same piece than my Couf Sup 1. But the Bottom end is fatter. Speaks much better in the middle and top registers. It is kind of it's own thing. you just got to play one.

bkiser
11-14-2004, 01:53 AM
I have pretty long fingers, though I tend to like the Selmer feel- light, close, no sharp edges, etc. I have played several Coufs and Keilwerths, so I understand what you are saying. I recently played a Selmer Reference 54 and loved the feel. I enjoyed playing it, however the sound didnt blow me away or anything. Probably because its so similar to my last alto (Selmer SA80 1). What I like about the "Selmer" sound is that it is so adaptable to any type music. However, if I found a horn with an equal or better feel and a richer sound to boot, it would be a done deal. I dont have the luxury of having a jazz horn and a legit horn, so I need a horn that can do both reasonably well.

jjgold
11-14-2004, 03:40 AM
BK..this horn is not a Selmer. It is it's own deal. It can get that buzz that alot of six players look for but I think the gold just makes it a more robust sound with a fatter bottom. My 2 cents.

saxforte
11-14-2004, 05:53 AM
bk,

Didn't mean to get on your case.
But you are close enough to make a visit practical, unlike most of our clients who rely on our unique way of doing business from greater distances.

Regards,
Mathew Aaron

bkiser
11-14-2004, 04:40 PM
Matthew- definitely didnt take it that way! I am still working on the road trip option. Unfortunately, the holidays are going to be pretty busy for me this year, and first quarter 2005 is packed with projects at work. On the plus side, project equal project bonuses, so maybe I could afford two altos after all! :twisted:

jjgold
11-21-2004, 02:56 AM
Ok...Like if anyone cares cause I noticed nobody wants to read these Rampone Threads. But, I got the horn back from my tech. He took the keys off put some cork in a few places that was making a little click noises. There were some minor leaks in the botttom stack. He changed some tension in some of the keys as well.

Well this is JUST ONE INCREDIBLE NEW HORN. Plays like the a cross between a Top Hat and A Super 20. But it has it's own thing going on. I am not sure what it is. Maybe it has to do with the gold plate? It can be VERY LOUD, smooth and bluesy or just straight ahead. The key feel is not tight like a Yama or Yani. It is a little slower.

I like the keilwerth horns but feel they loose something in the middle register. This horn seems to have it all. I think if anyone takes that plunge I just don't see how a true (I am not sure I am one) player could not love this horn? 8-)

bkiser
11-22-2004, 03:13 PM
I am giving mine a little time to break in, and myself a little time to knock the rust off, but cant wait to get the final adjustments made. Ive got no clicking, but a couple of small leaks in the bell notes (big surprise) and a little play in the octave mechanism which only shows up on G2. The action is a little slower than the Selmer Ref 54 I played, but only by a fraction. But...THE SOUND...you are completely right...it is its own thing, but does sort of resemble the Super 20, I think. its been quite a while since I played one. I always heard folks talk about the "buzz" of a good Mark 6, and this horn definitely has that going on. It definitely produces some volume, but mine is also very easy to control at lower dynamic levels- just enough back pressure to have some control. Have you made any recordings yet? I need to get busy on that as I suspect I dont sound as bright as I think I do (like you said- stand up against a wall and this huge, dark, complex tone shows up.